"The Ten Suggestions or A Royal Law of Love?"

Subject courtesy of the "United Church of God" and a pamphlet they sent me recently. I want to address the whole idea that the 10 Commandments apply to EVERYONE in the WHOLE world. I think it's sheer arrogance... but here is what else the United Church of God has to say on the issue.

Do the Ten Commandments have relevance to our every day life in this hectic and confusing 21st century?

Some people consider them to be only good suggestions, while others may make an attempt to practice some of them. Very few view these commandments for what they really are: the best advice our loving Creator can give us. They are designed to protect us, our families and communities.

Properly understood, these principles not only apply to today's world, but they can also transform the way we think and how we approach the problems and difficulties of life.

Ok, so apparently the 10 Commandments are just as valid now, as when Moses walked down Mt Sinai countless centuries ago... First lets go and find what the 10 Commandments actually are... as biblically stated versus the common understanding of what they are... because biblically there are actually two versions.

The first in the bible is actually from Exodus 20:2-17 (NIV) and the second version is from Deuteronomy 5:6-21 (NIV). There is also a set of 10 Commandments at Exodus 34:11-27, which are completely different to the first Exodus set and Deuteronomy. Wikipedia has usefully outlined the similarities and differences here so that I don't have to. Actually go and read the whole article, I can wait... its interesting.

Ah, you're back... so the 10 Commandments... are they actually still relevant in this day and age? All of these are taken from here which doesn't necessarily tie in with the NIV bible I have in front of me. Where significantly different, I'll comment...

ONE: 'You shall have no other gods before Me.'

Right... clearly this only applies to people who believe in the Christian-Judiac-Islamic God. There is no wiggle room here for Buddhists, Hindus, Confucians (??), Taoists, Atheists... or anyone who isn't Christian, Jewish or Muslim (though the Qu'ran has its own Commandments).

Clearly this fails the modern day understanding of freedom of religion being a human right.

TWO: 'You shall not make for yourself a carved image--any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth.'

I think many Christians fail this one... Muslims tend not to create sculpture or paintings of people for it is forbidden, and some Jews also don't have statues or paintings of people for the same reasons.

The actual bible quote refers to creating and worshipping idols, somewhat different to creating images and likeness of stuff. Oh and the original bible verse has God being a vengeful God... hardly the type of image that we want to propagate these days.

⁴ "You shall not make for yourself an idol in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below. ⁵ You shall not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, punishing the children for the sin of the fathers to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me, ⁶ but showing love to a thousand {generations} of those who love me and keep my commandments.

So, yes this one fails as well. Again assumes a belief in a certain God, and then tells you not to worship other stuff. Something that many people tend to forget... Evangelical Christian right in the US? Hello, can you hear me? Worshipping money and power? Bad people, naughty... big smacks.

THREE: 'You shall not take the name of the LORD your God in vain.'

Oh Jesus Christ! Oops did I just blaspheme? I don't typically say that phrase, but I think that most English speakers these days use, "Oh God" just as freely as they say, "and", "if" and "oops". Again this relies on a belief of a certain God, and for those who don't, clearly doesn't apply.

FOUR: 'Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy.'

Which Sabbath day? Exodus goes on to suggest that no one, not the Jews, the slaves, their animals or foreigners are allowed to work on the Sabbath, hence the Orthodox Jews not working on Saturdays, looking for ways to avoid working accidentally... you know by using light switches... I think that its all a little over the top, but that's their choice.

So, back to which Sabbath day... The Jews, the originators of the Old Testament of the Bible say that the Sabbath is Saturday, the last day of the week. Most Christians view Sunday as a holy day because that is when Jesus rose from the dead, and therefore is holy for that reason... the Sabbath moved thanks to Jesus. But Christians may attend a service or mass, but then continue on with the rest of their lives, working or whatever on Sunday... well these days anyway.

I think the Seventh Day Adventists returned the Sabbath to Saturday, but I don't know a lot about them, and haven't researched them, that's a story for another day.

So, again, this requires a particular belief in a particular God, because you're resting on "His" day of rest, so... it fails.

FIVE: 'Honor your father and your mother.'

Not a lot of leeway here. So what about the parent which abuses the child, physically, sexually or emotionally? Should that child honour their parents? I certainly wouldn't suggest so. That's gross betrayal, and certainly not good parenting according to anyone's idea of decent parents. We don't live in the dark ages any more. It'd be nice if the 10 Commandments didn't any more either. This one fails for not considering what happens to the children who are abused.

SIX: 'You shall not murder.'

Yay! One that passes. Apparently Catholic catechism goes one further and states that "You shall not kill... except in cases of capital punishment (though they'd prefer incarceration and rehabilitation) or war (if necessary and for good reasons).

So, standard ethics here... don't kill people because you don't want to live in a society where people could kill you. Killing is bad... m'kay?

SEVEN: 'You shall not commit adultery.'

According to the bible I commit adultery every second week night and every other weekend when I sleep with my other husband. Because men could have multiple wives back in biblical times, women however were the property of their husbands and didn't have the right to have multiple husbands. I'm fighting back against this trend... lets not also mention the bisexuality... that might make the bible writers head explode.

So adultery you reckon... what exactly is adultery?

Thanks to wikepedia (again)

Adultery is the voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and another person who is not that person's spouse. In most cases and especially in Western countries, only the married party is said to have committed adultery, and if both parties are married (but not to each other) then they both commit separate acts of adultery. In other countries, both parties to the adultery are considered guilty, while in others again only the woman is able to commit adultery and to be considered guilty. In some cases it is only considered adultery when a married woman has sexual relations with someone without the permission of her husband.

Right... actually on the basis that modern, so called Christian societies fail this one on a regular basis, I'm thinking of Governor Standford as a beautiful example here, and I'm sure you can think of other so-called Christian and perhaps even Jewish people who have had affairs and recognise that this standard is failed by society in general.

Given that I'm not a practiser of monogamy, can I actually be accused of adultery? If I cheated on my partners, then perhaps I could... I'll let this one pass only if we can redefine adultery to mean "cheating and lying" and then tie it into number 9 below.

EIGHT: 'You shall not steal.'

This one passes too. You don't want to live in a society where people steal your stuff, so you shouldn't steal their stuff. Nice simple ethics.

NINE: 'You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.'

This one passes too. Don't lie, be honest. Not that hard really... I don't care how much you don't like or even like your neighbour... being honest is the right thing to do.

TEN: 'You shall not covet your neighbor's house; you shall not covet your neighbor's wife, nor his male servant, nor his female servant, nor his ox, nor his donkey, nor anything that is your neighbor's.'

To covet:
1 : to wish for earnestly
2 : to desire (what belongs to another) inordinately or culpably (Merriam Dictionary)

What exactly is wrong with wanting something? I'd love to be as rich as... urm... Bill Gates, minus the tosseriness (and yes that is a word). I'd really like to have so much money that I can sleep on it, rub it all over my body, burn it to keep warm... and not have a care in my life. I don't... but what is wrong with wishing for that?

What is wrong for looking at a neighbour's or relative's house and thinking that I'd like something like that, or some item in that house? Provided I'm not stealing or lying about it, how is this wrong?

This one fails on being illogical. Its good to have dreams and its good to chase them... wishing or desiring an object, a status or lifestyle can provide the impetus to seek out those dreams. I'm all for coveting, so go right ahead.

So in summary, the 10 Commandments are not "A Royal Law of Love" and are not relevant to the 21st century. Lets find some other decent ethics and create a new and interesting moral society... I'm all for moral universalism myself.